Is This the Right Time for Me to Accept a Promotion?

Should I take this promotion?

Being put up for a promotion is often seen as the holy grail of career success. The validation of your hard work feels great, and the allure of more money, prestige, and respect can be appealing. 

But when the moment comes to decide whether or not you want to accept or ask for, a promotion, you may also feel an inner resistance. And it’s important to address that resistance because a promotion can often lead to more stress, anxiety, and potential burnout.

When You’re Put Up for a Promotion, Think Twice Before Accepting

One of my clients, Zane, was a manager at a large technology company. He was considered a “rock-star” on the fast track for growth. At the same time, his job was very demanding. He worked nights to keep up with his workload and was often distracted by work matters while at the dinner table with family. 

When Zane’s boss approached him about a promotion, he felt conflicted. Becoming a senior manager would boost his salary and offer bigger opportunities. But as someone who had suffered from imposter syndrome (which involves feeling like a fraud despite one’s achievements, and can cause feelings of anxiety), he also worried that the additional pressure would be more than he could handle — and be harmful to his mental health.

If you relate to Zane’s story, then you’re probably also wondering whether accepting a promotion is right for your career and your mental well-being.

Here’s how to figure out if a promotion is the best next step for you right now:

1. Do your research

Before accepting, gather the facts about the new role. Speak with your potential boss and team members to assess chemistry and fit. Make sure the scope and expectations are clear, not vague, and ambiguous.

Find out why the previous person exited the role. For example, if they quit, it’s possible that the culture was toxic, overly political, or that the workload was unsustainable. Then it might be that a promotion into that sort of environment is a bad idea.

2. Factor in your mental health

Workers like Zane fit into the mold of “Sensitive Strivers” — or those who tend to be committed and driven, sometimes to a fault. Because of this, I coached Zane to get radically honest about the potential toll that a promotion could have on his personal life.

Would the role be an increased burden to his already busy schedule? Was he ready for higher expectations and to have more riding on his judgments? Asking yourself these questions will tell you whether the title and money are worth the trade-off. 

3. Consider your professional path

A promotion should be a forward step in your career path, not a diversion. Evaluate whether the skills, competencies, and opportunities you’ll be exposed to align with your professional goals.

Some of my clients decline promotions that place them in team management positions because they prefer to become subject matter experts versus overseeing others. 

4. Lean on your core values

Think of your core values as principles that guide your professional choices and help you pursue a career that’s important to you.

If your core value is curiosity, for example, you’ll want to ensure that the new role allows you to experiment and innovate new ideas. Or perhaps you’re a new parent who values stability. A promotion that requires you to move across the country may not fit with your definition of success. 

5. Try a thought experiment, or two

On a scale of one to 10, how excited does the thought of taking the promotion make you? Now do the same for declining the promotion.

What do your responses tell you? You can also try acting for one day as if you’ve chosen to accept the role. Observe how you think and feel. Then, for another day, pretend as if you’ve declined the role. Take stock of your reactions. 

6. Put fear in its place 

It’s easy to convince yourself that you’re not ready or good enough for a promotion but look at the facts. Do you have a track record of delivering results and positive performance? Have you risen to challenges in the past? Could your skills gaps be bridged through experience and training?

Zane didn’t let self-doubt get the better of him. He took the promotion. It fit his professional ambitions and he felt confident about the team he was joining. Zane did an honest assessment of whether he had the capacity to take on additional responsibilities.

And he continued to work on important skills like setting boundaries and decision-making to make him successful in his new role without burning out.

© 2021 Melody Wilding // originally published on CNBC.

Recent Articles

Hi, I'm Melody

I help smart, sensitive high-achievers break free from imposter syndrome and overthinking so they can find the confidence to lead effectively.


Get exclusive access to Chapter One of Trust Yourself, on sale now, when you sign up for email updates below.

You can unsubscribe at any time. Your details are protected in accordance with my Privacy Policy.

Recent posts

Break free from imposter syndrome and Overwhelm

Discover which “growth gap” is causing your self-doubt and learn how to gain consistent confidence as a Sensitive Striver.

What's the #1 Cause Of Your Imposter Syndrome?

Stop the negative spiral of “I’m not enough” and increase your confidence, calm, and mastery of stressful situations.